Skip to main content

Up Close and Personal: Sherlock Holmes

It feels great to be back! My brief hiatus was due to my travels and then catching up with the final edits and cover design of my book scheduled for a December 2015 release with Srishti. The good news is we are making good progress and the cover should be out on Facebook very soon. I am excited and looking forward to your feedback!

In this edition and in the next few, I choose a topic close to my heart - looking at the private lives of the detectives we love. As a reader, I have always loved a thriller where I have been able to relate to the investigator as a human being. In my story, I have made sincere efforts to make Agni Mitra anything but an infallible, larger-than-life law enforcement machinery. And as we wait for Agni to share his life with us this December, let us revisit the lives of some of our favourite sleuths.

I look at Holmes this week.

In the accounts of Dr. Watson, Holmes comes across as bohemian and a tad eccentric. Holmes was also very apprehensive about destroying documents. (Here is one trait that I can relate to!) In the story "The Adventure of the Musgrave Ritual" Watson says:

He had a horror of destroying documents .... Thus month after month his papers accumulated, until every corner of the room was stacked with bundles of manuscript which were on no account to be burned, and which could not be put away save by their owner...

Holmes did not hesitate to often 'bend the rules' - take recourse to lying, conceal evidence, break into houses - if he considered such acts as morally justifiable. 

He derived utmost pleasure in baffling hapless police investigator with his superior deductions - sometimes almost to the point of arrogance. He felt happy when his skills were appreciated and he responded to flattery. In some cases, he actually comes across as a showman, taking pains in creating rather dramatic traps to capture his culprits and making an impression on his 'audience'!

However, Holmes does not actually come across as someone chasing fame. In a number of stories, he lets the police take public credit for his work! He comes across as a good friend of the police, and in a number of cases, the police seeks his assistance in solving a tricky one, even when he is on vacation. A number of his clients, of course, consulted him instead of or in addition to the police investigators.

With the honourable exception of Dr. Watson, we really do not come across a lot of friends! In fact, in "The Adventure of The Gloria Scott", Holmes tells Watson that during two years in college, he made only one friend - Victor Trevor. Well - that surely is a boy who preferred keeping to himself!

His love for music, especially the violin, of course is legendary.

So is his love for addictive drugs, especially when there was a lack of stimulating investigations. We read about Holmes using cocaine. We also find him dabbling in morphine. We also find several references of the use of tobacco, smoking cigarettes, cigars and of course, the trademark pipes. 

And now, about Holmes' attitude towards women.

Watson sums up the scenario rather nicely as:

(Holmes)"manifested no further interest in the client when once she had ceased to be the centre of one of his problems"

In "The Lion's Mane" Holmes himself writes:

"Women have seldom been an attraction to me, for my brain has always governed my heart"

In "The Adventure of the Second Stain" Holmes says:

"the motives of women ... so inscrutable .... How can you build on such quicksand? Their most trivial actions may mean volumes ..."

Irene Adler of course deserves special mention. An ex-opera singer and actress who appears in "A Scandal in Bohemia" and then remains the most memorable female character in popular Holmes-lore as the only female character who challenged him intellectually and the only person who defeated him in a battle of wits. Holmes held her in high regard:

"To Sherlock Holmes she is always the woman. I have seldom heard him mention her under any other name. In his eyes she eclipses and predominates the whole of her sex. It was not that he felt any emotion akin to love for Irene Adler ... yet there was but one woman to him, and that woman was the late Irene Adler, of dubious and questionable memory."

That memory is kept alive by the photograph Holmes received as 'remuneration' for his part in the case.

Some stories are best left unfinished.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Book Review - Museum of Memories: A soulful journey of many lives, through many eras and across many worlds

Amrita Mukherjee’s book ‘Museum of Memories’ (http://www.amazon.in/dp/9385854194/) is a collection of 13 short stories which, as the blurb suggests, are tales inspired by reality.
Reading through the stories, you find yourself looking into a kaleidoscope of emotions and Amrita, with her lucid language and superior storytelling skills, draws you into a world inhabited by characters you have grown up with, characters you run into everyday, and the person you look at every time you stand in front of the mirror.
In terms of structure, these are short stories that speak volumes and mostly end unpredictably. One can breeze through the book from cover to cover. However, they leave you with images, questions and thoughts to reflect upon long after the last page has been turned.
How do we embrace those close to us before they turn into memories? How does a woman who sells her womb for a price then grapple not just with the empty womb but an empty heart? What does destiny have in store for a sex…

Book Review - Onaatah of the earth by Paulami Duttagupta

Early on in the narrative, Paulami Duttagupta has to say this about Onaatah, the feisty protagonist of her novel ‘Onaatah of the earth’ (http://www.amazon.in/Onaatah-Earth-Adapted-National-winning/dp/9385854224):
‘ She looked rotten. Her face looked battered. But she didn’t want anybody to see her tears.’
This line pretty much sums up the courage and the grit of the (s)hero of Paulami’s story.
Based on the eponymous Khasi language film that won a National Award in 2016, Paulami’s novel is about a young girl who is subjected to brutal sexual violation after being abducted in a car by a gang of men that ironically includes one of her classmates from college, and who then fights back against archaic patriarchy, against the radical changes in attitude of those she had held close to her heart, and most importantly, against her own inner demons that her traumatic experience had unleashed.
In the early sections of her story, Paulami brilliantly depicts not just the physical sufferings but the em…

Book Review - Ajaya: Roll of the Dice by Anand Neelakantan

Ajaya: Epic of the Kaurava Clan by Anand Neelakantan published by Platinum Press (Leadstart Publishing) brings a unique perspective to the story of Mahabharata. In his introductory note, Neelakantan sets the premise of his work and is compellingly convincing in his characterization of Suyodhana, more (in)famously referred to as Duryodhana in popular lore, when he draws the reader’s attention to his unwavering determination to fight for his belief, his bravery and his strong personality. Neelakantan calls out incidents such as Suyodhana’s willingness to challenge the prevailing caste system by making Karna the king of Anga; his feelings for Ekalavya; his gallantry in taking on the Pandavas. At the same time, Neelakantan depicts him as a fallible human being, in sharp contrast with his cousins.

Neelakantan’s storytelling is lucid and he creates powerful imagery. Right from the ‘visually rich’ and dramatic entry of Bhishma into the palace of Gandhara to walk away with the princess Gandhar…